Oct 28, 2008

How Oil Prices Impact the Cost of Bottled Water

Bottled water is one of the best examples of energy waste and environmental pollution. Mayor Newsom in San Francisco encouraged restaurants to ban the service of bottled water. Few complied. If consumers were more aware, the US could easily waste much less. 

Let's analyze that cost in detail. 

A case of water with MSRP of $4.00 at retail might cost $1.00 at wholesale. Let's compute the fuel cost to move the water from Reno to San Francisco.
  • A container holds 1,440 cases of bottled water. 

Shipment Description

Commercial Freight Listing Information
  • Bottled Water/containers
  • Shipment Details: Bottled Water; 500ml/24 units per case. 72 cases per pallet; 20 pallets per container
  • Packaging: Palletized; 72 cases per Pallet
  • Dimensions(s):Pet Bottles/spring water-Drinking water
  • Total Weight:38000 lbs
  • Preferred Truck or Trailer:Container/40' rail
  • Special Permit Required:No

From Wikipedia: A highway trailor combination, pulling a 53 foot trailor, with a full legal load, and equipped with a commercial diesel engine of 300 to 400 hp, will get about 5 to 6 miles to the US gallon of diesel fuel, less in the mountains. 
  • The container travels 200 miles, a distance from Reno to San Francisco; or from Bakersfield to Los Angeles - and consumes 40 gallons of diesel. It consumes another 40 gallons as the container is distributed from the warehouse to retail stores. 
  • At $5 per gallon, that's $400 of gasoline or equivalent. 
  • Spread over 1,440 cases, the gasoline cost $0.28 per case. 
  • Add the energy cost of making the bottles, filtering, bottling, and loading trucks, energy costs are over 30%. It's the largest non-labor expense - more than water, chemicals, filters, plastic, and depreciation.
  • For the environment, don't forget the energy cost to dispose and recycle the plastic bottle.
Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update
U.S. Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Prices, 10/27/08
Regular Gasoline Prices Graph.On-Highway Diesel Fuel Prices Graph.
Gasoline  (Cents per Gallon)Diesel Fuel  (Cents per Gallon)
10/27/08Change from10/27/08Change from
 PriceWeek AgoYear Ago PriceWeek AgoYear Ago
U.S.265.6values are down-25.8values are down-21.6U.S.328.8values are down-19.4values are up13.1
East Coast268.4values are down-25.4values are down-14.9East Coast339.7values are down-15.6values are up24.9
  New England264.0values are down-22.4values are down-19.2  New England357.3values are down-15.6values are up32.3
  Central Atlantic276.6values are down-20.2values are down-7.5  Central Atlantic350.9values are down-12.4values are up25.8
  Lower Atlantic263.7values are down-30.0values are down-19.0  Lower Atlantic333.3values are down-17.0values are up23.8
Midwest249.7values are down-27.2values are down-36.7Midwest324.4values are down-20.3values are up12.2
Gulf Coast246.0values are down-27.4values are down-27.5Gulf Coast321.9values are down-23.4values are up15.7
Rocky Mountain276.2values are down-27.8values are down-11.1Rocky Mountain337.5values are down-18.0values are up9.4
West Coast305.0values are down-22.5values are down-4.1West Coast323.3values are down-20.0values are down-16.1
  California313.0values are down-22.5values are down-2.9  California328.6values are down-17.4values are down-12.0
Regional Regular Gasoline Prices Graph.Regional Diesel Fuel Prices Graph.
What We Pay For In A Gallon Of Regular Gasoline (September 2008) Retail Price: $3.70/gallon
What We Pay For In A Gallon Of Diesel (September 2008) Retail Price: $4.02/gallon


Crude oil prices have dropped more than 50% from it's height. Wholesale prices of gasoline have dropped and retail is sl0wly dropping. At 50% lower gasoline costs, producers save $0.14 per case; and shaves $0.56 from the MSRP - a 14% savings. We should see this savings soon in grocery stores.

If oil dropped another 50%, the savings is $0.07 per case - which would have a less significant impact on the retail price. This is the non-linear impact of price change that we first observed at MIT in 1972. No other historic data has been available to substantiate the non-linear impact of large price changes until recent history. Even with two data points, the fitted curve may still be statistically inaccurate. 
It is sufficient warning that dependence on imported oil endangers the stability of our economy - all developed economies.
If we eliminated bottled water, we'd save even more - for ourselves, our nation, and our environment. 

Conclusion

Generally, the price of every product and service is impacted by high energy costs. Products that are bulky and travel a long distance are more adversely affected. Conversely, when oil prices drop, MSRP should also drop significantly. 

In time, the 50% oil price drop stimulates the US economy dramatically - a fact that many 'chicken little' pundits have overlooked.